11 Internet download comforters (2025), tested in our homes throughout the ages
Compare our top comforters
We have tested many comforters
If you want a warm blanket but don’t want the traditional down, consider another option, or a comforter made of eucalyptus or bamboo.
Buffy Broel MOLOLLE: Buffy Broel MOLELERTER HAS BEEN DISCONTINUED FOR YEARS. It is made of eucalyptus fiber filling and has a eucalyptus fiber cover, which lends a silky feel and excellent heat regulation. It keeps me warm in the winter, but in the summer it doesn’t get too hot or too smoky. There are some great duvet covers available that I don’t quite like – the comforter turns inside out a little too much – but if you’re looking for a duvet cover, this one is well made and made of the same material. The best part is that buffy’s hot air is inexpensive, and it’s on sale just in time for basically every shopping holiday.
Lux Luxe Luxe Royal DOWN DOM COMDERTER company store: For the price, I admit that I expected this to be as high a premium comfort experience as one can get. And of course, the certified Legends RDS Luxury Luxe Lunke looks great, with a silk basket design on the hood, but it’s nothing like the same or fluffy feel as the brand’s Legends Line Line Line Line. Surprisingly, since it has a higher filling capacity than I like the legends Hotel Hotel COMORTER, Alberta’s Premium (700-750 to Alberta’s 600-650). And it’s not just me – at the time of the test, I tend to luxury legends Luxe Royal in Alberta, and he had been trying for three days before asking Alberta back. –Kat Merck
Photo: Kat Merck
Lacrosse Premium Down Of Medium Furferter: From the Company Store’s Flagship Lacrosse Collection, this RDS-certified comforter hits all the high points: snug comforter loops; The power of 600-650 fills; Cotton blend cotton cover. However, it’s around the same price as Legends Hotel Premium Alberta, above, which is much fluffier. –Kat Merck
Courtesy of Brooklinen
Brooklinen Airweave cotton blend: This fluffy stuffing is made of a weird, laid-back fabric that feels lightweight, airline, and fluffy but still manages to dissipate heat. (I tested it in Marigold, a fiery orange that brings me joy every time I see it.) My tester dress had a few loose threads, but careful plucking took care of them.
Another MOMForTERE sleeping utopia: If you’re on a tight budget, this inexpensive MOMdudumu drop offers great value for the price. It’s high quality and lightweight, but still warm despite not being too heavy. I wasn’t a big fan of the outer fabric – it’s the microfiber that I found to be scratchy and harsh. But the comforter is available in many colors (there are 11 to choose from), and it has loops in the corner to work with the duvet cover. And it’s well-constructed—I didn’t find a single loose thread or stitch, unlike other inexpensive comforters I’ve used in the past.
-Reviewer-Photo-SOURCE-Louryn-Strampe.jpg)
EDEN & OM Bamboo Comforter: This dress is soft-soft and quite thin. It can be a good option for a summer dress because it is cool in nature, or if it is spoiled, you may want to have a warm comforter around the grown-up night. Even though it’s a bit heavier, it doesn’t completely block the cold from My Box Fan, it keeps me warm enough in the brutal winter months. But on nights when it’s not wild outside, this dress reminds me of the buffy brow MOMOLERTER (above) – it feels like it controls my body temperature without making me too hot or too cold. It’s also breathable so on the off chance that I do sweat, I don’t wake up feeling stuffy and slippery.
Ikea fjällbräcka: I have used this IKEA border for several years. It’s not even 100 percent down (they cut it with duck feathers), it tends to get a little lumpy, and it’s not very high, but it has a 252 thread count shell that prevents feather leakage. The worst part is that the extra duck feathers give this comforter more of a “chicken smell” than white goose feathers. However, this comforter is also machine washable and sturdier than most quilts I’ve used at this price point. –Martin Cizmar
We do not recommend comforters
Courtesy of Wayfair
White noise goose down and feathers all time comforter: This mid-season comforter is breathable, balanced, and suitable for all seasons, with between 2 and 3 inches of 600 fill. The outer material is soft but feels different to the touch because it is made of polyester and nylon – although this helps with noise reduction and is quieter than others I have tested. The machine wash also strikes a great balance between being thin and light enough for warm weather while being big enough to still feel good. However, Comforter came with a really weird, healthy smell that smelled like grass and sweat. I showered and stopped two times to make the stench of the fence to sleep with, but every now and then during the test I can still smell the smell without stopping well. This is a solid comforter that strikes a good balance and has a great price point. I just wish it didn’t smell so bad. –Molly higgins
Down is the layer of fluffy feathers between the bird’s outer feathers and its skin. It’s a great thing to put in – just think of all those birds being able to stay warm and dry all year round. The bottom works well, it’s better than other materials, and it’s breathable even though things are always warm. The floor holds up well over time with proper care, so your initial investment will last for years. A down comforter is a great help if you live in a cold climate. Clothes made in other ways or other types of materials can be nice, too, but if you want a warm dress that will last for decades, maybe that’s what you’re looking for. We have a dedicated article to help you decide.
How do you choose a down comforter?
Look for a cover thread count between 230 and 500. Fabrics with these thread counts are “low” and reduce the chances of the feathers screaming.
Fill power vs. fill weight: Fill capacity is a measure of how much space, in cubic inches, an ounce of floor is taken for example, a fill capacity of 600 means 600 inches. A higher fill power means a fluffier, more efficient down. Fill energy does not mean that it translates correctly to warmth, but it is an indication of the quality of the floor and how much of the floor it is. Fill the weight, on the other hand, the bottom value of the product. If something has a high filling power but a low filling weight, it will not weigh less than if something has a low filling capacity and a high weight. It’s a bit confusing. The most important thing is how the floor is distributed. Look for a boxy or quilted construction on your comforters for an indication that the down will be evenly distributed and keep you warm all night. Odd boxes keep the floor high but need to be moved sometimes to reorient the interior, and shock – by keeping things in place but often result in a small comforter.
Goose vs Duck down: Goose Down has a higher filling power than goose down, so it is fluffier and higher. It is also hypoallergenic and hypoallergenic. On the other hand, ducks down are usually very cheap. We think goose down is the best unless you’re on a very tight budget. The two most common types of goose down are Hutersian and huterterite. Both are considered top-notch in terms of large collections down to the standard of birds from the cold regions of Hungary and Canada. Hutterteite tends to be more expensive. You probably won’t be able to tell the difference between the two. Hungarian down can be a bit stiff, and huterteite down can be soft, but ultimately none of these things should make or break your decision to buy a comforter. When it comes to the types of birds down there, however, you should be looking for all the goose down or at least a combination of goose and duck. That will reduce odors and allergens and provide a fluffier, higher-quality garment.
MOMFORTER Care Tips: If you’re investing in a comforter, you might want to consider getting a duvet cover, which can help protect the comforter and also often improve the look (unless you go in white. When it comes to washing the comforter itself, you want to follow the instructions on the care tag, and wash it as often as possible. You can do it at home if your washer is big enough; Alternatively, head to your local Laundrormot to use their big machines. Use a delicate high-speed wash cycle with high speed to get as much moisture as possible, and avoid using a soft cloth, which can damage the fabric. You should also use a small amount of detergent, not more, to ensure that all the soap is completely dry.
How do you test comforters?
For each comforter we tested, our testers spent at least seven nights of our choice in locations around the US – our testers included people living in Portland, Oregon; northern Illinois; New York City; and Kansas City, Missouri. Every Comforter on this list has been tested at least once in the fall, although most have been tested throughout. We were looking for comforters who struck a balance between price, efficiency, and quality, and wanted different filling materials, filling power, and materials to ensure our recommendations met the diverse needs of students. We assessed how we felt as we slept, slept, and woke up. We paid careful attention to details such as whether the comforter was noisy during your night’s stay, or whether any feathers ruffled. We are always testing new masters on the ground, especially during the colder months. We are also exploring other options below which will be covered in a separate article.
Power up with unlimited access to – Over there. Get best-in-class reporting and exclusive subscription content that’s too important to miss. Register today.
